Supreme Court stays Delhi municipal tax demand of ₹197 crore against NTPC for self-generated power usage

supreme-court-stays-delhi-municipal-tax-demand-of-₹197-crore-against-ntpc-for-self-generated-power-usage

Indu Bhan

The court requested a response from the Delhi civic body while maintaining the status quo regarding the tax demand.
The court requested a response from the Delhi civic body while maintaining the status quo regarding the tax demand.

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed the South Delhi Municipal Corporation’s ₹197 crore municipal electricity tax demand raised against the NTPC for the consumption of self-generated power at its Badarpur Thermal Power Station between 2006 and 2008. The stay was granted subject to NTPC depositing the principal amount of ₹82 crore with the court within two weeks.

A bench comprising Justices KV Viswanathan and Arun Palli, while seeking a response from the Delhi civic body and others, restrained the former from encashing the ₹197-crore demand draft furnished by the state-owned power producer after it lost the case in the Delhi High Court. Asking the parties to maintain the status quo for now, the apex court further said that the principal amount deposited by the NTPC will be kept in a fixed deposit. It posted the NTPC’s appeal for further hearing on February 9.

The HC in October had upheld the tax demand and Bye-Law 3(3) of the Delhi Municipal Corporation (Assessment and Collection of Tax on the Consumption, Sale or Supply of Electricity) Bye Laws, 1962 on the grounds that the taxable event under Section 113(2)(d) of The Municipal Corporation Act 1957 was consumption of electricity, and therefore, the auxiliary consumption by the NTPC at the Badarpur plant was consumption and a levy thereon does not, merely by reason of its use in the process of generation, constitute a duty of excise on generation.

In 2021, the civic body raised a demand for ₹197 crore, including interest against the NTPC towards electricity tax on the auxiliary consumption of electricity at the plant for 2006 to 2018. The NTPC then moved the HC challenging the demand and the provision under the 1962 Act that allowed electricity tax on consumption of self-generated power. The Badarpur Thermal Power plant had generated and supplied electricity until 2018 when it was shut down.

The NTPC told the SC that the consumption of electricity is to be understood as an incidence of generation itself. It further said that Section 113(2)(d) of the 1957 Act merely provided for imposition of tax on consumption, but Bye-Law 3(3) enlarged the scope of the word “consumption” to include consumption of self-generated electricity. Hence, Bye-Law 3(3) goes beyond the scope of the parent statute, it said.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the NTPC, argued that the electricity its plant consumed was used to generate electricity for supply to distribution licensees and, ultimately, end consumers, and not for its own end use. Such incidental consumption can neither be equated with own consumption under Bye-Law 3(3), he argued.

Further, the 2021 demand for 2006 to 2018 was barred by delay and laches, having never been assessed or demanded during the relevant period, the state-owned power producer said, adding that since electricity tax on the tariff-inclusive sale price had already been collected by the distribution licensees and remitted to the civic body, the separate levy on auxiliary consumption amounted to double taxation of the same economic component.

Join the community of 2M+ industry professionals.

Subscribe to Newsletter to get latest insights & analysis in your inbox.

All about ETEnergyworld industry right on your smartphone!